What to look at in live data
In the standard data, watch commanded EGR and the EGR error, which is how far actual position or flow differs from what was requested. With P0402 more exhaust gas gets in than intended: at idle, where EGR is usually closed or almost, the engine shakes and may stall, and calculated load and manifold pressure are higher than normal.
Watch idle at the moments when commanded EGR is at zero: if it is still unsteady then, the valve is stuck open, almost always with carbon deposits. On engines with a mass air flow sensor, an EGR valve that stays open makes the sensor read less fresh air than expected, even at idle. Before replacing the valve, check that the vacuum hoses (where the EGR is pneumatic) aren't swapped or loose.
How serious is it, can you drive?
Severity is medium, and whether to drive depends on how the engine behaves. If it runs well and doesn't stall, you can drive gently to the garage. If it stalls when you stop or lift off, take care at junctions and roundabouts: with the engine off, steering and brakes get heavier. In that case don't put it off.
Read P0402 on your car
With an OBD2 adapter, DrivePulse reads your car's fault codes and tells you what they mean, whether you can drive and what to check. It's read-only: it writes nothing to the ECU.
Get DrivePulseWhat it means
The EGR valve opens only in certain conditions, at part load with a warm engine, and stays shut at idle and at full load. The ECU checks how much gas flows with a position sensor on the valve and, on many engines, also from how the air measured by the MAF sensor or the manifold pressure changes.
With P0402 the measured flow is higher than the flow requested. It's the opposite of P0401, which reports too little flow. In most cases the valve doesn't close fully because carbon holds it off its seat.
Symptoms
- Rough idle that hunts or nearly dies.
- The engine stalling when you stop or lift off, especially when hot.
- Dark smoke from the exhaust, more obvious on diesels.
- Less pull at low revs and sluggish acceleration.
- Check engine light on; on some cars also limp mode with reduced power.
Most likely causes, in order
- A carboned-up EGR valve, stuck open or not returning to its seat.
- The valve position sensor, reading wrong even though the valve is fine.
- The valve connector or wiring, corroded or cooked by heat.
- The solenoid or vacuum hose, on vacuum-operated EGR valves.
- The MAF sensor or manifold pressure sensor, throwing off the flow calculation.
What to check before the garage
- If the idle hunts when hot and settles as soon as you touch the throttle, a valve that stays open is the first suspect.
- The EGR valve connector: it should be fully seated, with no corrosion and intact wires.
- On vacuum-operated valves, the vacuum hose: it shouldn't be cracked or loose.
- Skip the additives sold as EGR cleaners: they do little against hard deposits.
Why the engine stalls when you stop
At idle the engine needs all the fresh air that comes in, which is why the EGR valve must stay shut then. If it stays open, exhaust gas takes the place of air, combustion gets weak and the engine struggles to keep running. It happens more with a hot engine and the air conditioning on.
For the same reason the fault fades or disappears when you accelerate: with more air coming in, the share of exhaust gas counts for less.
At the garage: what to ask for
A live reading of the requested and actual valve position, and an open-and-close test commanded from the scan tool. Then removal to see how much carbon there is. In order of cost: connector or vacuum hose, valve cleaning, new valve. If the valve was very dirty, ask them to look at the intake manifold too.
What DrivePulse shows
DrivePulse reads P0402 and opens its card, with the clue to look for (rough idle and smoke point to a valve stuck open) and the advice to have it cleaned at a garage; it also says whether the code is pending or confirmed.
On the live dashboard you see the idle RPM: if it swings a lot when hot, that's the typical pattern. In live data the MAF sensor gives another clue: with the valve staying open, the fresh air measured at idle is lower than usual.
Frequently asked questions
Can I drive with P0402?
If the engine doesn't stall, yes, gently to the garage. If it stalls when you stop, don't put it off: it's a risk at junctions.
What's the difference from P0401?
P0401 says too little gas is flowing through the EGR valve. P0402 says too much is, usually because the valve stays open.
Is cleaning the EGR valve enough?
Often, yes, if the problem is carbon and the position sensor works. If the valve is worn or the sensor has failed, it needs replacing.
Related codes
Related guides
- Buying a used car? What to check: a code cleared just before the sale shows up in the distance driven since the last clear.
What you need to read it
All you need is an ELM327 OBD2 adapter, plugged into the diagnostic port, usually under the steering wheel. On iPhone it has to be Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) or Wi-Fi, like the Veepeak OBDCheck BLE or the Vgate iCar Pro 2S; on Android classic Bluetooth adapters work too, once paired in the phone's settings. Veepeak recommends DrivePulse to its customers, and the Vgate is the one the Italian site Macitynet tested together with the app. The full list is on Which adapters work.
DrivePulse is on iPhone and Android. It's read-only: it writes nothing to the ECU and doesn't clear codes. You try it for 7 days from the first connection or for 15 trips, whichever comes first, then unlock it with a single purchase, no subscription and no account.